Junk fees are not mere line items on a bill. They represent a significant expense that can impact both consumer spending and merchant profitability. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) has highlighted that hidden fees cost American consumers billions each year, often buried in the fine print of transaction agreements.
One of these newly targeted junk fees is the credit card surcharge imposed by merchants. But businesses are not spared from these expenses either. The Merchants Payments Coalition reports that merchants paid over $100.75 billion in credit card processing fees in 2023, an increase of $7.5 billion from the previous year. Small businesses often face charges as high as 4% per transaction, while larger corporations might negotiate rates closer to 2%.
Junk fees are closely connected to other pricing strategies like drip pricing and surcharging. Junk fees are unexpected charges not tied to any specific service. Drip pricing reveals costs incrementally, masking the true total until the final stages of a purchase. Surcharging adds a fee specifically for credit card users. All three affect consumer perception, market transparency and the purchasing decision.
What is a junk fee?
Junk fee is a catch-all term for additional charges that appear unexpectedly during transactions, inflating the cost of services or purchases and often disclosed only at the point of sale. Unlike standard service fees, which cover actual costs, junk fees often lack clear justification and can feel arbitrary or deceptive.
- Service charges: added to bills in hospitality or services without a direct correlation to service improvements.
- Processing fees: attached to ticket sales, loan applications or real estate transactions, often labeled “handling” or “administration” fees.
- Resort fees: charged daily by hotels for amenities that are sometimes unrequested or underused.
- Preparation fees: charges for preparing documents or reports that may not require the effort implied.
Why are junk fees problematic?
Junk fees distort the true price of products and services, complicating decisions for consumers. They undermine trust when fees appear hidden or manipulative, and they disproportionately impact financially vulnerable populations who may not be able to absorb unexpected costs.
- Lack of transparency: fees are often not disclosed clearly at the time of a transaction, leading to surprise when the final bill is higher than expected.
- Distorted choices: consumers may opt for a product based on an inaccurately low advertised price, only to find it much costlier at the point of sale.
- Unfair competition: businesses that don’t charge these fees can appear more expensive upfront and lose customers to competitors who add fees later.
Drip pricing
Drip pricing is a strategy where a business presents a low base price to attract customers, then adds fees as the customer progresses through the purchase. The final price ends up significantly higher than advertised.
- The attraction. Customers are drawn in by an attractively low advertised price.
- The increment. As the customer moves forward, incremental fees appear: service charges, resort fees, taxes or mandatory cleaning fees.
- The checkout. By the payment stage, the cumulative cost is considerably higher than expected.
Consumers react in two ways: immediate abandonment once they see the total, or reluctant acceptance with a reduced likelihood of returning. Given its potential to mislead, drip pricing has caught regulators’ attention. In 2024 the FTC increased enforcement against deceptive pricing practices, arguing that transparency is not just ethical but crucial for fair competition.
Surcharging
Surcharging is an additional fee merchants add when a customer pays with a credit card, used to cover processing costs by passing a portion of the expense to the consumer.
- Fee application: when a customer pays by credit card, the merchant adds a percentage-based fee, typically 3% or more, on top of the purchase price.
- Disclosure: regulations often require these fees to be clearly disclosed before the transaction is completed.
Surcharging differs from junk fees and drip pricing in key ways. It is directly tied to a payment method rather than appearing arbitrary. It is heavily regulated, with strict disclosure rules and percentage caps in many jurisdictions. And it applies only when the consumer chooses a credit card, though in a digital-focused economy cash is barely an option anymore.
Some consumers accept surcharges as a reasonable trade-off for convenience, security and rewards. Others view them as an unwelcome extra cost. For businesses, a surcharge can offset costs but may discourage purchases, particularly if competitors don’t impose one. And surcharging can make things worse: adding 3% or more to the cost of everything, on top of an already inflated market. While the consumer, the business and the processor are all involved, the processor benefits most, taking its own fees on top of the surcharge the consumer pays. The result is a negative perception of the business, a higher cost for the consumer and substantial profit for the processor.
Legislation & regulatory actions targeting junk fees
Regulatory scrutiny and legislative action aimed at reducing or eliminating junk fees has increased at both the federal and state level.
Federal initiatives
- CFPB: launched a crackdown on junk fees in 2023 and proposed rules requiring clearer disclosure of fees in banking, real estate and entertainment, including pushing banks to display all potential fees upfront when opening an account or applying for loans.
- FTC: has taken enforcement action against deceptive fee practices, including a 2024 case against bill-payment company doxo, which agreed to pay millions in refunds for misleading consumers about fees tacked on during the payment process.
State-specific legislation
- California: effective July 2024, stringent laws require service providers to disclose all additional fees before a transaction is finalized, covering industries from automotive sales to online retail.
- New York: a transparency act mandates that fees considered “non-essential” must be included in the advertised price, aimed particularly at hidden fees in travel and leisure.
Impact on businesses & consumers
For consumers, upfront pricing builds trust, reduces disputes and makes purchasing decisions more secure. For businesses, the transition requires overhauling how prices are presented and may cause an initial dip in sales as prices appear higher without hidden fees. In the long run, businesses that prioritize transparency are likely to see stronger customer loyalty.
How junk fees distort competition
Junk fees create an uneven playing field where transparent pricing is not the norm. Two competing hotels might list the same nightly rate, but one adds resort fees the other doesn’t, misleading consumers into choosing the seemingly cheaper option. When the full cost isn’t clear upfront, decisions are based on incomplete information, and trust erodes across whole market segments.
Companies that adopt transparent pricing can find themselves at a disadvantage when their visible prices look higher than competitors who add fees later. New entrants may feel pressured to adopt the same tactics to compete. In response, regulators have begun enforcing stricter disclosure requirements, and companies are reevaluating how they price: incorporating all fees into advertised prices, improving the clarity and timing of disclosures and marketing transparency as a selling point.
Is credit card fee surcharging a junk fee?
First, a clarification: many people mix up credit card late fees with credit card surcharges when talking about junk fees. Processing fees are essential costs businesses pay to a combination of card networks, issuing banks and payment processors. Surcharges are fees merchants add on top of the purchase price for customers who pay by credit card.
Credit card processing involves several types of fees:
- Interchange fees. Paid to the card-issuing bank to cover handling, fraud and bad-debt costs and the risk of approving the payment. Typically the largest portion of processing expense.
- Assessment fees. Charged by the card networks (Visa, Mastercard, American Express) for using their networks. Smaller than interchange but still significant.
- Payment processor fees. Charged by the processing company for transaction processing, merchant account services and payment gateway provision.
- Additional fees. Setup, monthly usage, minimum-usage penalties, transaction fees and charges for chargebacks or refunds.
Combined, processing fees typically range from 1.5% to over 3.5% per transaction. Interchange fees are influenced by card type and brand, transaction method, security features and rewards programs. Visa and Mastercard publish interchange tables with over 1,500 different card types and tiers.
Processors impose fees above interchange with complex billing models. Flat-rate pricing from companies like Square, Stripe and QuickBooks can seem straightforward but cost merchants more than necessary. Debit card interchange might start as low as 0.25%, but flat-rate pricing pushes these fees toward 2.79% + $0.30 per transaction. On a $5 sale, that structure pushes the cost of payments above 8%, which helps explain why some businesses set minimum spends for card acceptance.
Predatory pricing issues
The processing industry faces criticism for what some see as predatory pricing. Additional layers of fees can be added above interchange, sometimes as much as 300 basis points (3%). The opacity of processing statements and the arbitrary addition of fees under the guise of regulatory or compliance enhancements make it difficult for merchants to anticipate the true cost of accepting cards. There is currently no dedicated regulatory body overseeing these practices within the processing industry, so fees can be increased with minimal notice.
Potential regulation
Regulators are contemplating whether some aspects of surcharging qualify as junk fees: unnecessary or excessively high charges that don’t correspond to the service provided. Agencies like the CFPB and FTC have examined processing fees to determine whether they unfairly burden consumers and merchants, and whether they should be capped or more clearly disclosed. The 2024 Visa and Mastercard swipe-fee settlement with U.S. merchants, which drew public statements from Senators Dick Durbin and Roger Marshall, was one step toward transparency and fairness in the industry.
State responses to surcharging
Credit card surcharging is subject to both card-network rules and state laws. Here is a summary of the landscape as of late 2024:
- Federal and network rules: surcharges are capped at 4% and cannot exceed the merchant’s actual cost of acceptance. Surcharging debit cards is not permitted in any state.
- Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts: surcharging credit card transactions is illegal.
- Colorado: allows surcharging up to 2%.
- Illinois: permits surcharging up to 1% or the cost of the processing fee, whichever is less.
- New York, New Jersey, Nevada, South Dakota: prohibit surcharges from exceeding the cost the merchant pays to accept the card.
- Texas: prohibits surcharging but allows convenience fees, service fees and cash discounts.
- California, Kansas: had anti-surcharging laws overturned by federal courts. Merchants must include credit card fees in the listed price to legally impose a surcharge.
- Alabama, Alaska, Arizona: surcharging is legal as long as it meets federal and network guidelines.
This debate is likely to produce more definitive regulations that balance the needs of consumers, businesses and payment processors. Key areas of focus include standardizing fees across states to prevent a confusing patchwork, and enhancing competition among processors to lower costs for merchants.
If you can’t surcharge consumers, at least reduce your expenses
At VeriFee, we understand the challenges businesses face with junk fees and complex processing charges. Leveraging over 20 years of industry experience, we specialize in reducing these costs through expert negotiation and AI-powered analysis, without changing your existing payment processors, hardware or software.
Our approach
- Fee analysis & optimization: thorough audits of your current processing fees and contracts to identify unnecessary charges and areas for cost reduction.
- Negotiation & renegotiation: we negotiate with service providers on your behalf to lower or eliminate excessive processing fees and unjustified junk fees.
- Ongoing monitoring & support: continuous monitoring and reevaluation of your processing arrangements so you always enjoy the best possible terms as the regulatory landscape changes.
Benefits to your business
- Cost savings: minimize unnecessary spending on fees, increasing overall profitability.
- Enhanced transparency: a clearer understanding of the fees you’re charged and why.
- No impact to operations: no changes to processing vendors, equipment, software or POS systems, no applications or underwriting and no impact to daily operations.
If you’re looking to cut credit card processing expenses and get ahead of junk-fee regulations, reach out to us.
Related reading
Credit card surcharge laws by state: the 2026 compliance guide →


